Premier League admits 'significant' VAR error cost Manchester United in derby defeat

The Premier League has formally acknowledged a “significant” VAR error that handed Manchester City a 1-0 victory over Manchester United at Old Trafford on September 13, sending a written statement to all clubs ahead of their latest shareholders’ meeting.

Erling Haaland’s winner was initially ruled out for offside by the on-field officials, only for VAR to intervene and overturn the call — incorrectly, as Enzo Fernández had attacked Josko Gvardiol’s cross from an offside position. The two VAR officials responsible for the decision, Matt Donohue and Blake Antrobus, have since been stood down from their duties until after the international break.

The league’s statement to clubs, reported by The Times, read: “Despite a positive start, early season officiating performance has been overshadowed by a significant VAR error in the Manchester United v Manchester City match on Sunday, September 13. The VAR did not recognise an offside offence by Enzo Fernández and incorrectly overturned the original decision of offside to allow the goal to stand. Pro Ref are undertaking a full review of the incident, which will be reviewed by the Premier League, with learnings being adopted immediately.”

Pro Ref chief Howard Webb had already conceded the outcome was an “error of judgement”, saying he was “really disappointed” and that the officials involved were “obviously hurting” having “fallen short in this situation”.

The derby controversy has intensified broader scrutiny on both VAR and Pro Ref, with Webb said to be under mounting pressure. The incident followed complaints from Arsenal manager Mikel Arteta over a separate penalty call during his side’s 2-0 win over Sunderland, adding further weight to calls for greater accountability in officiating.

Gary Neville, who was commentating on the derby, predicted at the time that an apology would be issued to Manchester United — a forecast that has now effectively been borne out by the league’s written admission to clubs.