KMI panel rules Arsenal should have had penalty after Havertz held in offside position against Hull
An independent Key Match Incidents panel has unanimously found that Arsenal were wrongly denied a penalty against Hull City on November 7, ruling that Nobel Mendy's hold on Kai Havertz occurred before any offside offence was committed.
An independent Key Match Incidents (KMI) panel has unanimously ruled that Arsenal should have been awarded a penalty in their match against Hull City at the Emirates Stadium on November 7, after Kai Havertz was held back by Nobel Mendy while in an offside position.
Referee Farai Hallam gave nothing on the pitch, and although VAR Michael Oliver recommended a review, no spot-kick was awarded on the grounds that Havertz was offside at the time. The five-person panel determined that the penalty should have been given both on the field and following VAR review, citing the chronology of events as decisive.
The panel’s reasoning centred on Law 11, which states that a player in an offside position is only penalised upon becoming involved in active play. Because Mendy’s hold preceded any potential offside offence by Havertz, the panel concluded the foul should have taken precedence.
The same panel also unanimously disagreed with the decision not to award Coventry a penalty against Everton on November 6, when James Tarkowski pulled the hair of Caleb Yirenkyi. The panel concluded that the incident warranted a spot-kick and a yellow card for Tarkowski.
In contrast, the panel unanimously backed the decision to allow Manchester United’s equaliser to stand in their 4-4 draw with Aston Villa on November 8. Replays suggested United goalkeeper Senne Lammens may have impeded Zion Suzuki when challenging for the ball, but the panel was satisfied the contact lacked sufficient impact to constitute a foul.
The panel was split over a challenge by Leeds’ Jayden Bogle on Tottenham’s Mathys Tel on November 7. Two members believed referee John Brooks should have shown Bogle a red card and that VAR Tony Harrington should have intervened, but the majority of three felt the contact, while clearly reckless, fell below the threshold for a dismissal and backed the on-field decision.
Across ten match rounds assessed so far this season, 223 KMIs have been reviewed. On-field decisions were deemed correct 85 per cent of the time, a figure that rises to 97 per cent following VAR intervention.
Read also
-
Football ·Infantino's re-election bid strengthens as AFC reverses stance despite UEFA opposition
-
Football ·Deschamps held talks with Manchester United before Pochettino landed the job
-
Football ·Pochettino touches down at Carrington with Liverpool at Anfield looming on Sunday
-
Football ·Real Madrid extends Arda Güler through 2032, valued at €100m
-
Football ·FIFA tender documents suggest hydration breaks set to stay for 2030 World Cup
-
Football ·Arsenal face unpopular contract calls as Odegaard and Havertz renewals stall
Switzerland U17