SportsCatch
EN

Sport integrity expert dismisses 'lazy' claim as Man City await punishment after 114-charge guilty verdict

A leading sport integrity expert has pushed back against suggestions that delays in sentencing Manchester City are due to negligence, insisting justice must be served without shortcuts. City were found guilty of 114 of 115 Premier League financial charges and have since appealed.

2 min read
Sport integrity expert dismisses 'lazy' claim as Man City await punishment after 114-charge guilty verdict
Share

Manchester City remain in limbo over their punishment after being found guilty of 114 of the 115 Premier League financial charges brought against them, with a sport integrity expert now addressing growing frustration over the length of the process.

Emanuel Macedo de Medeiros, co-founder and global chief executive of the Sport Integrity Global Alliance (SIGA), told the Press Association that the delay in publishing a sentence is not a sign of negligence. “That is not because those who are in charge of the procedures are lazy, or they neglect their duties,” he said. “It’s because there cannot be room for doubt. There cannot be room for failure.”

The independent panel’s September ruling found that City had intended to breach financial rules by inflating revenues or reducing costs by more than £900m through a series of arrangements it described as ‘sham’. Central to the findings was a ‘disguised funding scheme’ in which companies from Abu Dhabi paid only a fraction of the sums recorded in the club’s books, with the remainder settled by Abu Dhabi United Group — the vehicle through which Sheikh Mansour owns the club. That arrangement was found to have inflated City’s revenue by more than £830m across the nine seasons between 2009-10 and 2017-18.

The panel also found City had overstated income from image rights by almost £74m and understated liabilities for staff contracts by almost £17m.

City have appealed the verdict and maintain their innocence. In their formal response to the ruling, the club stated it contained “clear material errors of law, principle and fact, and is unsafe.” CEO Ferran Soriano told staff in a video message that the panel had sided with what he characterised as a Premier League “conspiracy theory.”

With the appeal ongoing, speculation over potential punishments has been widespread. Scenarios discussed publicly include significant points deductions, transfer bans, substantial fines, and even expulsion from the Premier League — reflecting the unprecedented scale of the case.

Macedo de Medeiros acknowledged the difficulty of the wait for supporters on both sides, but stressed that speed should not come at the expense of due process. “I understand the fans’ frustration, and I understand also the fans’ anguish, especially those who follow and support Manchester City,” he said. “This is not a pleasant situation for anybody, but the law is the law, and it must be served on its own time, without constraints.”

He added that, despite the delays, he believes the process is nearing its conclusion: “I think it’s fair to say that the process is coming to an end.”

Share
{# Sitewide native fullscreen interstitial — our own bet-CTA card blown up to a takeover (replaces the SDK overlay). The shared card animations + countdown load once, AFTER the interstitial markup, so the countdown script's first tick sees this card's node too (the in-read card, in
above, already exists). One include covers both surfaces. #}