SportsCatch
EN

Ratcliffe's £40m manager merry-go-round proves United's culture remains broken

Sir Jim Ratcliffe once identified Manchester United's revolving door of managers as the root of the club's decline, yet the combined cost of hiring and firing Erik ten Hag, Ruben Amorim, and Dan Ashworth has now reached an estimated £40 million — with Mauricio Pochettino becoming the eighth permanent head coach since Sir Alex Ferguson retired.

2 min read
Ratcliffe's £40m manager merry-go-round proves United's culture remains broken
Share

Mauricio Pochettino has been appointed Manchester United’s eighth permanent manager since Sir Alex Ferguson’s retirement in 2013, arriving at Old Trafford after Michael Carrick was sacked just six months into a permanent contract following the club’s worst start to a season in four decades.

The appointment carries a familiar sting for minority owner Sir Jim Ratcliffe. When he acquired his stake in 2024, Ratcliffe was explicit about the damage caused by managerial instability. “If you look at the 11 years that have gone since David Gill and Sir Alex stepped down, there have been a whole series of coaches, some of which were very good,” he said. “None of them was successful or survived for very long, and you can’t blame all the coaches. The only conclusion you can draw is that the environment in which they were working didn’t work.”

Those words now sit awkwardly alongside the club’s recent record. Erik ten Hag, who was still in post when Ratcliffe made that assessment, was dismissed roughly ten months later. Ruben Amorim succeeded him and lasted just over a year at Old Trafford. According to The Athletic, the combined cost of appointing and dismissing Ten Hag, Amorim, and sporting director Dan Ashworth amounts to approximately £40 million.

Carrick’s exit adds another chapter to the same story. Handed a permanent deal only six months before his dismissal, he becomes the latest casualty of a cycle Ratcliffe once vowed to break.

Pochettino, 54, has signed a two-and-a-half-year contract and faces United’s clash with Liverpool as his first assignment. United icon Gary Neville has urged the Argentine to negotiate carefully before settling in. “I’m hoping Mauricio Pochettino has done a couple of things on the way in and I’m hoping he protects himself on his contract because he’ll need to,” Neville said. “I’m sure he’s stated that he needs a massive budget. I think he needs defenders straight away to get Manchester United anywhere near where they want to be this season. And the other thing is to make sure that he takes control of the recruitment because it’s quite clear that what happened in the summer is well below the standard again. He’s got to come in here and protect himself.”

Neville’s warning underlines the scale of the task facing Pochettino — not just on the pitch, but within a structure that has so far consumed four managers and £40 million in severance and compensation since Ratcliffe arrived promising change.

Share
{# Sitewide native fullscreen interstitial — our own bet-CTA card blown up to a takeover (replaces the SDK overlay). The shared card animations + countdown load once, AFTER the interstitial markup, so the countdown script's first tick sees this card's node too (the in-read card, in
above, already exists). One include covers both surfaces. #}