Ralf Schumacher dismisses Herta's Cadillac F1 seat hopes despite super licence milestone
Colton Herta completed 24 laps at Interlagos to secure his FIA super licence, but former F1 driver Ralf Schumacher has bluntly rejected the American's chances of landing a Cadillac race seat, citing a poor Formula 2 campaign and finishing nine tenths behind Valtteri Bottas in practice.
Colton Herta secured the final super licence point he needed during first practice at the 2026 São Paulo Grand Prix, completing 24 laps at Interlagos in place of Sergio Perez. On paper, the Cadillac test driver is now eligible to race in Formula 1 from 2027. In practice, not everyone is convinced he should.
Ralf Schumacher, the former F1 driver now working as a pundit, delivered a withering verdict when asked whether Herta could partner Perez at Cadillac. “Only if Easter and Christmas fall on the same day,” Schumacher said. “Seriously, it’s pointless. He’s just burning fuel, to borrow a phrase from Franz Tost. I don’t even know what the point of it is. You might as well put someone else in the car, give some young drivers a chance.”
Schumacher’s sharpest criticism was directed at Herta’s Formula 2 season, which the American entered specifically to accumulate super licence points and demonstrate readiness for F1. It has not gone to plan. Herta currently sits 19th in the F2 standings with 26 points, without a victory or podium finish. Even Formula 2 CEO Bruno Michel has acknowledged that Herta has struggled more than anticipated.
“He was really that bad in Formula 2,” Schumacher said. “As far as I’m concerned, he hasn’t earned it at all. I think it’s great that they’re trying to promote American drivers. But it has to make sense, and he has no place in Formula 1.”
Herta ultimately secured his super licence through a combination of IndyCar results — nine race wins and a runner-up finish in the 2024 championship — and points accumulated through Friday practice outings with Cadillac. His performance at Interlagos did little to silence the doubters: he ended the session approximately nine tenths of a second slower than Bottas.
Schumacher suggested McLaren junior Leonardo Fornaroli, a champion in both Formula 2 and Formula 3, as the kind of candidate who would make more sense. Beyond that, he acknowledged that finding the right second driver for Cadillac would be “very, very difficult”.
One of Cadillac’s 2027 seats is already settled. Perez extended his contract with the team through to 2029 at the end of October. The status of Bottas’s deal remains unclear, and several names are in circulation for the second seat. George Russell has publicly backed Mercedes junior Frederik Vesti as a candidate.
Read also
-
Formula 1 ·Piastri takes 10-place grid drop at Las Vegas GP after McLaren forced into fifth engine
-
Formula 1 ·Wolff recalls teenage Antonelli sleeping on his couch before 2026 title triumph
-
Formula 1 ·Piastri takes 10-place grid penalty in Las Vegas after McLaren fits fifth engine
-
Formula 1 ·Wolff skipped Brazil party to toast Mercedes' 2026 double with a vodka shot on the plane
-
Formula 1 ·Wolff explains why Russell will be denied Mercedes' new turbo in Las Vegas
-
Formula 1 ·Lawson's 2026 revival earns him Racing Bulls seat for 2027, says Permane
Switzerland U17