Premier League chief Masters asks clubs to share legal costs as City sponsors threaten defamation suits
Richard Masters is seeking collective indemnity from all 20 Premier League clubs ahead of a London meeting on Thursday, after Etihad Airways and Etisalat signalled legal action following Manchester City's £900m revenue-inflation ruling.
Premier League chief executive Richard Masters is asking all 20 clubs to collectively cover the board’s legal costs and any damages if Manchester City’s sponsors follow through on threats to sue the league for corporate defamation, according to a report from The Times.
The request is set to be tabled at a league-wide meeting in London on Thursday. A document circulated to clubs ahead of the gathering proposes that member clubs share financial responsibility for any legal action brought by a third party against the five-person board — currently comprised of Masters, Alison Brittain, Mai Fyfield, Dharmash Mistry and Matthew Ryder KC. The document makes no direct mention of City, their sponsors, or the 115-charges case, but insiders are said to view it as a direct response to the sponsor threat.
The backdrop is the independent commission ruling, handed down roughly two months ago, that found Manchester City guilty of artificially inflating club revenue by £900 million through what it described as ‘sham’ contracts with sponsors between 2008 and 2019. Masters subsequently stated that City had ‘systematically broken Premier League rules for nearly a decade’. City, who were formally charged in February 2023, deny any wrongdoing and have appealed the verdict.
Within 24 hours of that ruling, front-of-shirt and stadium sponsor Etihad Airways announced it was considering legal action against the Premier League, citing multiple complaints. Telecommunications giant Etisalat — valued at more than £40 billion — followed on Monday, describing findings related to the company as ‘entirely false and defamatory’ and confirming it was weighing its legal options.
The league has since recognised that its board currently holds no indemnity against third-party legal claims. Article 35 of the Premier League’s articles of association only allows a director’s legal expenses to be reimbursed if they win the case — a provision that offers little protection against a defamation action that could run into the billions, particularly if pursued in the United States, where corporate defamation awards have previously exceeded the billion-pound mark and both parties bear their own costs regardless of outcome.
The Premier League declined to comment when contacted.
Read also
-
Football ·Drone operator films Pochettino's first Manchester United training session from unrestricted airspace
-
Football ·Torres reveals how Alonso and Mascherano exits forced his £50m Chelsea move
-
Football ·Monaco extends Paris Brunner's contract by two years following breakthrough start to season
-
Football ·England fined and handed suspended ticket ban after anti-Catholic chanting in Madrid
-
Football ·Man City and Forest outvoted 18-2 as Premier League shields board from Etihad lawsuit threat
-
Football ·Neymar insults Coritiba supporters after Santos victory
Belgium U17