Benfica poised to make Echeverri's £17.5m Man City loan permanent after encouraging start
Claudio Echeverri has impressed Benfica boss Marco Silva during his loan spell in Portugal, with the club holding a €21m option to sign the Manchester City midfielder permanently at the end of the season.
Claudio Echeverri looks increasingly likely to leave Manchester City on a permanent basis, with Benfica set to exercise their €21 million purchase option at the end of the season after the Argentine midfielder has shown steady improvement under manager Marco Silva.
Echeverri, 20, joined City from River Plate for £12.5 million in 2024 but has spent virtually his entire time at the club out on loan. His move to Benfica in September was his third loan spell in 12 months, following a stint back in Argentina and an ill-fated spell at Bayer Leverkusen that was cut short in January. A loan at Girona also ended in disappointment, with the Spanish club relegated to the second tier.
The midfielder reached a personal milestone this month when he started a league game for Benfica against Estrela — his first league start anywhere since May 1, ending a 191-day wait. He has made seven appearances in all competitions for the Portuguese club, including starts in the Europa League.
Silva has spoken positively about Echeverri’s development since arriving in Lisbon, though he stopped short of confirming the club will trigger the purchase option. “I’d say we have plenty of time to assess him and integrate him into the team,” Silva said. “And I’m not talking about quality. Because he’s got plenty of quality. If he didn’t, we wouldn’t have made that move so close to the end of the window.”
The Benfica manager added that no decision would be rushed. “We don’t usually make decisions based solely on one or two months, or on two or three matches. I’m certain the player will contribute a great deal and that he will improve. At the right time, we’ll make the decisions that will always be in Benfica’s best interests.”
Echeverri had shown flashes of his ability at City level — most notably with a surprise appearance off the bench in the 2024 FA Cup final against Manchester United — but never established himself in Pep Guardiola’s plans. Guardiola publicly criticised the player’s representatives, and Echeverri was subsequently moved on loan.
If Benfica proceed with the €21 million option, City would recoup considerably more than the £12.5 million they originally paid River Plate, bringing a quiet end to an association that never truly got started at the Etihad.
Read also
-
Football ·Pochettino eyes Thiaw signing as United weigh Chido Obi loan recall for January
-
Football ·Griezmann crowned MLS Rookie of the Year 2026, ahead of overlooked Lloris
-
Football ·Barthez judges Restes 'unconvincing' and reopens France's number two goalkeeper debate
-
Football ·Haaland's 96th-minute penalty completes Norway's comeback to stun Denmark in Copenhagen
-
Football ·Devenny's stunning strike sends Northern Ireland into Nations League top flight
-
Football ·Fernandes physically restrains red-carded Neto as Portugal edge Wales 3-2 in Nations League